AFGHANISTAN- A FRENEMY & A GRAVEYARD FOR THE EMPIRES
History is great teacher, if one
takes cues from it and move on keeping the events in view.
The image above is seen worldwide
is much more than a few Taliban occupying the table in the Presidential Palace
of Afghanistan, but is for the framed painting put up on the wall that everyone
seems to miss.
The painting is of one Seer in
white, Darbesh Shah, blessing a person bowed in his front with a bunch of
ripened wheat grass, a symbol of prosperity.
The person getting blessed is
Ahmed Shah Abdali, the most respected Afghan ruler in history. We would soon
discover more about him in a gist.
Afghan history is sharpened with events
that are resplendent with treachery and deceit. So, I am befuddled, as to why,
the world is feigning ignorance. History strikes hardest to the society that
feigns ignorance.
The modern day Afghanistan is
largely credited to Ahmed Shah Abdali, who later assumed the name as Ahmed Shah
Durrani.
Around 1738, at an age of
sixteen, he was taken in by Nader Shah Afshar, the ruler of Persia, as Garrison
Commander of Afghans.
The modern day Afghanistan is
carved out of such empires by Ahmed Shah Abdali, who travelled as Afghan
Garrison Commander with Nadir Shah to loot and plunder India many times. Nader
was assassinated in 1747 by his own confidants.
Abdali, a confidant of Nader
Shah, also betrayed Nader Shah after his death in 1747 and took the Kohinoor
ring, which Shah had looted from the India. Abdali took that Kohinoor ring from
the dead body of Nader Shah’s finger and wore it and declared himself as ruler.
It was Nader Shah who gave Ahmed
Shah Abdali the name of Durre Durrani- The pearl of the era.
Ahmed Shah took the name of Ahmed Shah Durrani then on.
The Afghans chose Durrani as
their head of state Durrani and his Afghan army conquered most of
present-day Afghanistan, Pakistan, and part of Iran. He even defeated the
Indian Maratha Empire, and one of his biggest victories was the 1761
Battle of Panipat, a battleground where history of India has a long trail.
So, the medieval history, rolling into
twenty first Century, of Central Asia & Persian Gulf Region is a history of
power, greed, betrayal and blood on hand and boundaries getting defined with
every victory and defeat.
So, I do not see why the world is
blaming Taliban for Afghanistan mess. Tribal wars & holy wars are part of
their legacies and the country & the region is at constant wars amongst
warlords for riches and outreach.
I prefer to call Afghanistan a FRENEMY-
a country that pretends to be friend but in fact is
not so in reality for the precise historical reasons above. Afghan army even
attacked India in Kashmir & occupied on behalf of Pakistan an area that we
know today as POK or Pakistan Occupied Kashmir.
This must be the Afghan lesson
that USA learnt after being bitten twice & shied several times in
Afghanistan.
History has witnessed Afghanistan as a
proven “graveyard of empires”, from 19th-century British Empire to the
20th-century Soviet empire & now America.
It seems that in past two decadal
years & more, every step that USA took was a misstep. Thus the turn of
events in Afghanistan has been alarming but not surprising.
The Taliban’s rapid takeover
of the country culminating in their march to the capital was almost unopposed
as President Ashraf Ghani fled the country- allegedly with 150 million US
Dollars in Cash.
This is a clear pointer that democracy
cannot be forced through the gullet to a society that has never believed in the
power of democracy and has proceeded the way it has in its own way- the
tribalistic ruthlessness for ethnic cleansing and holy wars.
USA’s idea of democracy fell flat on its
face in Afghanistan where religious hardliners rules above all and any voice
against it is silenced by a bullet.
The recent Trump administration’s
decision to engage the Taliban diplomatically was the beginning of the US
surrendering to the hardliner groups. Biden administration just hastened that
process by complete withdrawal.
But was it really inevitable and
a fait-accompli?
As I see it- US always controlled
the timings of its troop deployments, but the Taliban had the time at hand.
More importantly- Taliban had the will.
As a matter of fact, since World
War II, the US has failed to decisively win any major war, whether in Korea,
Vietnam, Iraq or Afghanistan.
The humiliation may be the one silver
lining after the two decades of tragedy & horrific wars in the greater
Middle East as Oil is no more the liquid gold and USA need to stop the plunder
and pounding for the pot of gold at the end of the rainbow.
From mid twentieth Century
onwards, the raiders & the raided have switched positions and reverse
plundering started of Middle East & Central Asia, thanks to its rich oil
& gas finds and critical minerals needed for twenty first century.
Now the emerging Superpowers,
like China, Russia have recognised the Taliban for Government formation for the
simple reason of raiding and usurping its mineral wealth and to capitalise on
its strategic location in scheme of the thing like BRI / OBOR initiative of
China.
In due course of time, USA would also
recognise Taliban Government for its long term strategic interests- it cannot
afford to lose its foothold in the region. It can ill afford to give the
deckhand now to China & Russia.
In larger scheme of the things,
India does not stand anywhere despite its claims of investments of three
billion US Dollar, a paltry sum by global standards and the countries that it
poses to stand with, in that country.
It was clear when Trump
administration struck a deal with Taliban in Doha in February 2020 for peaceful
US troop withdrawals. India was not even invited initially to the table as a
stakeholder & desperately sought backchannel diplomatic route to have a
seat, but no say.
The new state players, like
China, are just looking at the prospect of Afghanistan from materialistic point
of view and are emboldened by their Pakistan support (what a fallacy China is
living with them).
Afghanistan is rich in resources like copper, gold,
oil, natural gas, uranium, bauxite, coal, rare earths, lithium and many other
mineral deposits. It was estimated to be worth more than three trillion US
Dollars during the last commodity super cycle. China is precisely looking at
prospecting those mining deposits.
But taming Afghanistan would be
much harder than the Central Asian grassland countries under erstwhile USSR.
Taliban can give China a taste of their
own noodles and can easily renegade from all commitments. Indeed, it would the
matching of the minds that we must observe very closely as it unfolds.
In the words of the ancient Greek
emperor, Alexander, wars are easy to march into but hard to
march out of.
China could be the next empire that just
may find it facing the syndrome of Afghanistan blight- A Graveyard for Empires.